Does Time Under Tension Actually Matter For Muscle Growth?
Does time under tension actually matter for muscle growth? You have the studies and the science that's saying one thing, and then you have the best in the world at this are saying another. The answer is that rep speed barely matters on its own, and it matters a lot as a tool for a specific problem.
The research leaves little room for argument once you look past the headlines. With that said, we also have to acknowledge that the anecdotal or the practical knowledge that comes from high-level professional bodybuilders is also something that we have to consider, because those guys are solving a problem the studies were never designed to ask about.
So that you understand the mechanism here, okay? When a muscle fiber carries enough force, that force is what tells it to build. The term for that is mechanical tension, which just means the load a fiber actually carries while it is shortening or lengthening against resistance.
So when you lift lighter weight, obviously your muscle makes less total force. In this case, fewer fibers are what switch on during that movement or that set, right? And that's exactly why a lighter set, lower weight, typically needs to have more volume because as your muscles become fatigued, more fibers are recruited so that you can continue to push the necessary force that's being expected of the body.
That ordering is not a theory somebody made up in a gym. Henneman and colleagues described it in 1965: motor units get recruited from smallest to largest based on how much force the task demands, so the big high-threshold fibers only come online when the small ones can no longer do the job (Henneman 1965).
Which is why fatigue is doing something useful rather than just making you tired. As the small units give out, the nervous system has to call the big ones in to keep the bar moving, and those big ones are the ones with the most growth potential sitting on them.
So if I pick up a pin, I kind of have an idea in my mind subconsciously of how much this weighs. The theory is that my body is only going to recruit enough muscle fibers to move that specific amount of weight.
Grab a cable stack somebody lightened without telling you and you get that jolt, that whoa, because you overshot your own estimate. Go the other way, try to pick up something heavier than you expected, and it just does not move.
And this is exactly why you see with deadlifters when they're a high-level strength athlete, when they warm up, even when they're doing a lighter weight warm-up, you know, their work-up sets, like 225, 315, 405, you know, for some guys, 495, they work their way up to something respectable, which is closer to 500, 600 pounds, they're still moving the weight at the same speed. They keep the same intent on every single set, no matter how light the bar feels relative to where they're headed. They are priming the nervous system to fire at full output before the weight ever gets heavy.
This also means that there's a psychological piece that you have to consider, which is being willing to push your body beyond what you believe it's capable of. Most guys think they've gone to failure when they're far from it, and on a low volume program the room for error is tiny, because if you only do two hard sets and both of them stop three reps short, you did nothing.
The controlled trials tell a different part of the story. Schoenfeld and his group pooled the controlled tempo studies and found that anywhere from a half a second to an eight second per rep movement grew the same muscle when sets went to failure (Schoenfeld 2015). And as a follow-up, reps that took 10 or more seconds actually looked worse.
So if I'm intentionally doing a very, very, very slow negative type time under tension of a rep that's 10 seconds or more, it's actually less effective for muscle growth. The likely reason is simple: at that speed you cannot carry enough load to make the force meaningful, so you are buying seconds and paying for them in tension.
There's a catch worth noting before you take any of this as settled. A lot of that data came from untrained subjects, not bodybuilders, so you are watching beginners respond to almost anything you throw at them.
And what they also found was that because of this correlation between volume and reaching failure paired with the time under tension conversation, any weight from about 30% of your max up to your max did the same job at failure. Mitchell and colleagues ran exactly that comparison, 30 percent of max to failure against 80 percent of max to failure, and after ten weeks the muscle growth was the same (Mitchell 2012). The lighter load just demanded a lot more reps to get there.
So again, when it comes to time under tension, what this study is showing is that it doesn't really matter as long as you reach failure and your reps aren't longer than 10 seconds. That's what that means.
However, when we did a lighter weight, tempo did change the result. So at 30 to 50% of their max, three seconds down and three seconds up with no rest between reps built muscle, where normal speed reps at the same weight didn't.
Read that carefully, because it tells you what tempo is actually for. With a weight that light, normal speed reps let you cheat the muscle with momentum and brief unloading at the top and bottom, so the set ends before the big motor units ever get called in. Slow it down, kill the rest between reps, and the muscle has no escape, so you reach the same recruitment ceiling with a third of the load. Burd and colleagues showed the same thing from the other direction, where slower reps at 30 percent of max produced a longer-lasting protein synthesis response than fast reps at the identical weight (Burd 2010).
That's an important thing to understand, right? Because the biggest reason why bodybuilders, especially at the high level, have a tendency to focus on more slow, controlled, especially eccentrics, they typically say about a four second eccentric, is because they understand that you get so big and strong that the more weight you lift, the higher your risk of injury.
Four seconds down, pause, no momentum, then drive it up as fast as possible. The pause strips the stretch reflex out of the bottom position so the muscle has to start the weight from a dead stop, which is why the same dumbbell feels twice as heavy on rep six.
How can we do this in a way that's going to minimize the risk of injury without losing the benefit that we're looking for, in this case, the muscle growth? So this is an intentional and deliberate strategy that they're applying so that they can go into the gym and get the benefit that they're looking for without the downside, right? Because if an Olympia-level bodybuilder gets injured lifting a heavy weight, doing barbell squats or something at the beginning of a season, this is going to completely destroy his entire prep.
His whole career rides on avoiding that outcome, since the sport is also how he makes his living. Same math as an NFL player blowing a knee.
Phil Heath makes the case better than anyone else I could point to. He trained almost entirely on machines, got outcomes equal to or better than the barbell guys, and he came out the other side intact. And if you look at him now, I think he's 46.
Ronnie Coleman is the other end of that trade. Arguably the greatest open bodybuilder who ever lived, and it cost him most of his mobility for the rest of his life. He would probably tell you he would do it again, which is a real answer, but it is his answer and not necessarily yours.
So the question becomes what you are actually training for. I think I turn 39 next week, and my priorities have shifted completely from what they were at 25, when I wanted to jack a bunch of weight and it was an ego thing.
The question I ask now is how little weight I can use and still get the growth stimulus. You know, right now I sit at about 225, 235 pounds, depending upon where I'm at with my nutrition. I think for me, at most, I would be OK at like maybe a 250 at the same body fat percentage.
Research: Henneman 1965 (PMID 14328454); Schoenfeld 2015 (PMID 25601394); Mitchell 2012 (PMID 22518835); Burd 2010 (PMID 20711498).
References
Schoenfeld B, Ogborn D, Krieger J. Effect of repetition duration during resistance training on muscle hypertrophy: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sports Med. 2015;45(4):577-85. PMID: 25601394. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25601394/
Mitchell C, Churchward-Venne T, West D et al. Resistance exercise load does not determine training-mediated hypertrophic gains in young men. J Appl Physiol (1985). 2012;113(1):71-7. PMID: 22518835. PMCID: PMC3404827. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22518835/
Burd N, West D, Staples A et al. Low-load high volume resistance exercise stimulates muscle protein synthesis more than high-load low volume resistance exercise in young men. PLoS One. 2010;5(8):e12033. PMID: 20711498. PMCID: PMC2918506. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20711498/
Schoenfeld B, Grgic J, Ogborn D et al. Strength and Hypertrophy Adaptations Between Low- vs. High-Load Resistance Training: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. J Strength Cond Res. 2017;31(12):3508-3523. PMID: 28834797. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28834797/
HENNEMAN E, SOMJEN G, CARPENTER D. FUNCTIONAL SIGNIFICANCE OF CELL SIZE IN SPINAL MOTONEURONS. J Neurophysiol. 1965;28:560-80. PMID: 14328454. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14328454/
Schoenfeld B. The mechanisms of muscle hypertrophy and their application to resistance training. J Strength Cond Res. 2010;24(10):2857-72. PMID: 20847704. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20847704/
If this is the kind of information you want access to on a daily basis, the community is free and there are full courses on training, nutrition, hormones, and supplementation inside. You can ask questions and post your own labs and get feedback from me and from the community.